Adding Salt to Ice in a Cooler

Why do people sometimes add salt to ice in a cooler for drinks or beer?  It’s a simple question.  There are tons of articles and videos online but I couldn’t find a comprehensive explanation of why it works.

Some Basics

It’s important to first understand what melting point and freezing point mean.

Melting point is a property of solids.  The melting point is simply the temperature at which the solid turns into a liquid.  For example, the melting point of normal ice is 0°C at standard pressure.

Freezing point is a property of liquids.  The freezing point is simply the temperature at which the liquid turns into a solid.  Thus the freezing point of normal freshwater is 0°C.

The value of the melting and freezing points is the same (ie. both are 0°C for water).

So as you can see, melting point and freezing point are kind of “mirrors” of each other.

It doesn’t make sense to talk about the freezing point of a solid (since it’s already solidified).

What Does Salt Do?

When salt is added to water it lowers the freezing point.  In other words the water needs to be chilled to a temperature lower than 0°C (say -2°C for example) in order to change to ice.  Another way to say the same thing is that salt allows water to exist as a liquid at a temperature lower than 0°C.  This is the important part that’s relevant to beer coolers.  We’ll come back to this later.

For completeness let’s look at this from the perspective of melting point.  When salt is added to ice it lowers the melting point.  In other words the ice begins melting at a temperature lower than 0°C.  This is why salt is added to ice on the roads in the winter.  It causes ice, that would have otherwise remained as a solid in sub-zero temperatures, to turn to water.  Note that the temperature of the water has not changed.  It’s still at a sub-zero temperature but, as mentioned above, the salt allows it to remain as a liquid at the lower temperature.  Don’t think that just because the salted-ice has become water the temperature has risen.

How Does this Apply to Beer Coolers?

In two ways: chilling beers fast and keeping beers cold.

Chilling Beers Fast

An important part of chilling beer fast is to maximize how much of the can/bottle’s surface area is in contact with the chilling agent, whether it’s ice, water, or cold air.

Salt-water lets you chill a warm beer really fast — much faster than a freezer [1].  Pour cold water, ice, and salt into the cooler to create a salt-water-ice bath.  Why does it work?  The ice will be at a temperature way below zero, usually -18°C for a household freezer [2].   The ice will cool the water down and the salt will allow the water temperature to drop below 0°C.  The beer will then be fully submersed in sub-zero water, maximizing the surface area in contact.

Without salt the water will remain at a temperature slightly higher than 0°C even though you have -18°C ice cubes floating in it.  The water will still get quite cold and will do a good job but not as cold as salt-water.

If you only put ice in the cooler then less of the beer’s surface is touching the chilling agent (ice) since ice cubes are irregularly-shaped.  It won’t chill the beer as fast as salt-water.

Keeping Beers Cold

If your goal is to keep the beer cold for a long time (ie. if you go camping or on a picnic) it’s still a good idea to add some water and salt to the ice because it will make your beers colder initially which means they’ll stay cold longer.  The salt will make the ice melt as well but the resulting water will still be very cold.  The specific heat capacity of water is double that of ice [3], which means, in theory, the sub-zero water will stay colder longer than plain ice will.  You could argue that the starting temperature of ice is much lower (-18°C) than sub-zero water (which might be just a few degrees below 0°C).  So it’s a bit of a tradeoff.  Also, adding salt to the water does lower its heat capacity but not by much [4].

Note: you need lots of salt (handfuls) for the above stuff to work.  Table salt is fine.

References

  1. http://youtu.be/k3PvQXlxvZY
  2. http://www.inspection.gc.ca/food/consumer-centre/food-safety-tips/food-handling/kitchen/eng/1329169036268/1329169127007
  3. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Properties_of_water#Water.2C_ice_and_vapor
  4. http://www.kayelaby.npl.co.uk/general_physics/2_7/2_7_9.html
About these ads

12 thoughts on “Adding Salt to Ice in a Cooler

    • Bill, thanks for posting this link. It explains, and has other links, for the underlying chemistry of why salt lowers the melting point of ice.

      • I have mixed snow &alot of salt in a bucket & put in homemade foam cooler so when spring came along I was able to keep my food cold for a couple months

  1. Have you ever considered creating an ebook or guest authoring
    on other blogs? I have a blog centered on the same
    information you discuss and would really like to have you share some stories/information.
    I know my audience would value your work.
    If you are even remotely interested, feel
    free to send me an e mail.

  2. Pingback: Garlic Mojo Apple Cider Smoked Whole Hog | Sometimes Spicy, Always Tasty

  3. Pingback: Garlic Mojo and Apple Cider Marinated Smoked Whole Hog | Sometimes Spicy, Always Tasty

  4. Pingback: Think You Can’t Drink Coffee? Read This! - Demo Wordpress

  5. Mixing salt with ice is an endothermic reaction, meaning that it takes its energy (heat) from the surrounding environment (water) to melt the ice quicker than it would naturally melt. It will lower the temperature of the water below 0deg. This is why the ice cube challenge causes such severe burns.

  6. Pingback: Wine 101: Wine Hacks | My Wine Canada

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s